The Workplace Investigation Process in Australia: A Step-by-Step Guide
When a serious complaint lands on your desk, you need to know the process you are about to start. A workplace investigation is a structured, impartial process for establishing the facts behind an allegation so the organisation can make a fair, defensible decision.
This guide explains each stage of a workplace investigation in Australia and what good practice looks like at every step.
What is a workplace investigation?
A workplace investigation gathers and weighs evidence about alleged conduct (such as bullying, harassment, discrimination, or misconduct) and reaches findings on whether the allegations are substantiated. Findings are made on the balance of probabilities: whether it is more likely than not that something happened. This is the civil standard, not the criminal "beyond reasonable doubt."
The investigator establishes the facts. The organisation then decides what to do with those facts. Keeping those two roles distinct is important.
Step 1: Assess the complaint and define the scope
Before anyone is interviewed, the matter needs to be scoped. This means:
- Clarifying exactly what is being alleged.
- Drafting clear, specific allegations (called particulars), each one a single, testable statement of fact.
- Deciding which policies, codes, or legal standards apply.
- Identifying who needs to be interviewed and what documents are relevant.
Poorly defined allegations are one of the most common reasons an investigation goes wrong. Vague allegations cannot be fairly answered or fairly tested.
Step 2: Plan the investigation
A good investigator prepares an investigation plan: the order of interviews, the questions for each witness, the documents to request, and the timeframe. Planning also addresses confidentiality, interim measures to protect the parties, and any support such as access to an EAP.
Step 3: Gather the evidence
Evidence usually falls into three categories:
- Documentary: emails, messages, rosters, CCTV, policies, prior warnings.
- Witness accounts: from people who saw or heard relevant events.
- The parties' own accounts: the complainant and the respondent.
The investigator collects this evidence methodically and keeps a clear record of where each piece came from.
Step 4: Interview the parties and witnesses
Interviews are the heart of most investigations. As a rule:
- The complainant is interviewed first to confirm the detail of the allegations.
- The respondent is then put on notice of the specific allegations and given a genuine opportunity to respond, a cornerstone of procedural fairness.
- Witnesses are interviewed to corroborate or contradict the accounts.
Interviews should be conducted in a way that is calm, neutral, and trauma-informed. Each person is usually entitled to a support person. The investigator records what is said accurately, often in a written statement the witness reviews.
Step 5: Assess the evidence and make findings
With the evidence gathered, the investigator weighs it against each allegation. This involves assessing credibility, reliability, consistency, and corroboration, and applying the balance of probabilities. For serious allegations, the evidence must be correspondingly stronger before a finding is made (a principle drawn from the well-known Briginshaw standard).
Each allegation is then found to be substantiated, not substantiated, or unable to be determined.
Step 6: Deliver the report
The investigator produces a written report that sets out the allegations, the evidence considered, the analysis, and the findings. A good report is clear, structured, and free of jargon, so decision-makers can act on it with confidence. Investigators usually make findings of fact; whether they also make recommendations depends on the brief.
Step 7: Act on the outcome
Armed with the findings, the organisation decides on next steps, which may include disciplinary action, mediation, training, or policy changes. Where conduct is substantiated, any action must still be fair and proportionate, and the respondent should have a chance to respond before a serious sanction such as dismissal.
How long does it take?
It depends on complexity, the number of witnesses, and availability. A straightforward matter might take two to four weeks; complex matters take longer. We explore this in How Long Should a Workplace Investigation Take?.
Getting it right
A well-run investigation protects your people and your organisation. A poorly run one can be worse than no investigation at all, exposing you to claims of unfair process. If you would like an experienced, impartial investigator, Adomas Solutions conducts workplace investigations across Tasmania and remotely throughout Australia.
Have a matter you would like to discuss? Contact us for a confidential conversation, or browse our FAQ for quick answers.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. For advice about a specific matter, contact us or seek independent legal counsel.
Keep reading
How to Prepare for a Workplace Investigation Interview
Practical guidance for anyone asked to attend a workplace investigation interview, whether as the complainant, the respondent, or a witness, so you can take part calmly and fairly.
The Positive Duty to Prevent Sexual Harassment: What It Means for Employers
Australian employers now have a positive duty to prevent workplace sexual harassment, not just respond to it. Here is what the duty requires and how to meet it.