Skip to main content

Procedural Fairness in Workplace Investigations: An Employer's Guide

22 April 20263 min read

If an investigation finding is ever challenged (at the Fair Work Commission, in court, or internally), the first thing scrutinised is usually not what was decided, but how. That is the domain of procedural fairness, also called natural justice. Get it wrong and even a well-evidenced finding can be set aside.

This guide explains what procedural fairness requires and how to build it into every investigation.

What is procedural fairness?

Procedural fairness is the principle that decisions affecting a person should be made through a fair process. In a workplace investigation it has two core rules:

  1. The hearing rule: a person must know the case against them and have a genuine opportunity to respond before a decision is made.
  2. The bias rule: the decision must be made by someone impartial, free of actual or perceived bias.

A third related idea, the evidence rule, requires that findings be based on relevant, logically probative evidence, not suspicion or rumour.

Why it matters

Australian employers operate under the Fair Work system, where dismissals and disciplinary decisions can be challenged. The Fair Work Commission routinely considers whether a fair process was followed. A finding produced through an unfair process is vulnerable, regardless of whether the underlying conduct occurred. Beyond legal risk, a fair process protects trust, morale, and your organisation's reputation.

The hearing rule in practice

To satisfy the hearing rule:

  • Put the specific allegations to the respondent. General accusations ("your behaviour has been inappropriate") are not enough. The person must know the particulars: what they are said to have done, to whom, and when.
  • Give them enough information to respond. This includes the substance of the evidence against them, even if a witness's identity is sometimes protected.
  • Allow adequate time. Don't demand an immediate answer to serious allegations; give a reasonable opportunity to prepare.
  • Genuinely consider the response. The opportunity to respond must be real, not a box-ticking exercise after the decision is effectively made.
  • Allow a support person. While not always a strict legal requirement, refusing one can count against the fairness of the process.

The bias rule in practice

  • Choose an impartial decision-maker. The investigator should have no personal stake in the outcome and no close relationship with the parties.
  • Watch for perceived bias. It is not enough to be impartial; a fair-minded observer must also see the process as impartial. A complainant's direct manager investigating the complaint often fails this test.
  • Keep an open mind. Avoid forming a conclusion before the evidence is gathered and the respondent has answered.

This is one of the strongest arguments for an external investigator: read When to Use an Independent Investigator vs Investigating Internally.

The evidence rule in practice

Findings must rest on evidence. That means:

  • Making findings on the balance of probabilities, with stronger evidence required for more serious allegations (the Briginshaw principle).
  • Distinguishing direct evidence from assumption.
  • Documenting the reasoning so the path from evidence to finding is transparent.

Confidentiality and fairness can coexist

Employers sometimes believe fairness conflicts with protecting a complainant. It need not. You can maintain confidentiality and still give the respondent the substance of the allegations. What you cannot do is make a finding against someone who was never told what they were accused of.

A quick procedural-fairness checklist

  • Allegations are specific and in writing.
  • The respondent received the particulars and the substance of the evidence.
  • The respondent had reasonable time and a support person.
  • The respondent's response was genuinely considered.
  • The investigator is impartial and free of perceived bias.
  • Findings are based on evidence and clearly reasoned.

Where this fits in the wider process

Procedural fairness runs through every stage of the workplace investigation process. Skipping it is one of the most common and costly mistakes employers make.

Adomas Solutions conducts impartial workplace investigations built around procedural fairness, with extensive law enforcement experience and a court-level evidentiary approach. To discuss a matter, contact us for a confidential conversation, or see our FAQ.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. For advice about a specific matter, contact us or seek independent legal counsel.

Confidential, no obligation

Need help with a workplace matter?

Adomas Solutions provides independent workplace investigations across Tasmania and remotely throughout Australia. Get in touch for a confidential, no-obligation discussion.

Confidential & no-obligation · (03) 6292 6046 · [email protected]