When to Use an Independent Investigator vs Investigating Internally
Not every workplace complaint needs an external investigator, but some absolutely do. Choosing the wrong path can waste time, damage trust, and leave your decision exposed if it is later challenged. So how do you decide?
This guide sets out when an internal investigation is appropriate and when bringing in an independent investigator is the safer, smarter choice.
When an internal investigation can work
Handling a matter in-house can be reasonable when:
- The allegation is relatively minor and the facts are largely undisputed.
- You have a trained, genuinely impartial person available, typically in HR, with no relationship to the parties and no stake in the outcome.
- There is no significant power imbalance or seniority issue.
- The matter is unlikely to result in serious disciplinary action or external challenge.
For lower-level interpersonal issues, a prompt internal response or facilitated conversation is often the proportionate option.
When to engage an independent investigator
An external investigator is usually the better choice when one or more of these apply:
1. The allegations are serious
Where the conduct could lead to dismissal, or involves sexual harassment, assault, fraud, or significant safety breaches, the stakes are high. A serious matter demands a robust, defensible process.
2. There is a real or perceived conflict of interest
If the people who would normally investigate are connected to the parties, as friends, managers, or rivals, any finding is open to a claim of bias. As we explain in Procedural Fairness in Workplace Investigations, perceived bias is enough to undermine a finding. An independent investigator removes that risk.
3. Senior people are involved
When the respondent is an executive, owner, or board member, few internal staff can investigate without fear or favour. External independence protects both the organisation and the individual.
4. The matter is complex or contested
Multiple allegations, many witnesses, conflicting accounts, or significant documentary evidence call for specialist investigative skill and time that internal teams rarely have spare.
5. You lack internal capacity or expertise
Running a fair investigation is a skilled task. If no one internally has the training, time, or confidence to do it properly and promptly, outsourcing protects everyone, including the complainant and respondent.
6. The outcome is likely to be challenged
If you anticipate a Fair Work claim, a discrimination complaint, or litigation, an independent, professionally documented investigation carries far more weight than an internal one.
The benefits of independence
- Credibility. Parties are more likely to accept an outcome reached by a neutral third party.
- Defensibility. A professional investigation built on procedural fairness stands up to scrutiny.
- Objectivity. An outsider is not influenced by office politics, history, or relationships.
- Capacity. Your team stays focused on running the business while the matter is handled properly.
- Specialist skill. Experienced investigators know how to scope allegations, interview effectively, and weigh evidence to the right standard.
The trade-offs to weigh
External investigations involve a cost and require briefing an outsider on your organisation. For minor matters that an impartial internal person can resolve quickly, that may be unnecessary. The key is proportionality: match the process to the seriousness and risk of the matter.
A simple decision guide
Ask yourself:
- Could this realistically lead to dismissal or external legal action?
- Is there any perceived bias if we investigate internally?
- Are senior people or a power imbalance involved?
- Is the matter complex or hotly contested?
- Do we genuinely have an impartial, capable person with time to do this well?
If you answered "yes" to any of questions 1–4, or "no" to question 5, an independent investigator is likely the right call.
How we can help
Adomas Solutions provides independent, impartial workplace investigations with extensive law enforcement experience and a trauma-informed approach. Whether you need a full investigation or just advice on the right path, contact us for a confidential discussion.
For more background, see The Workplace Investigation Process in Australia and our FAQ.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. For advice about a specific matter, contact us or seek independent legal counsel.
Keep reading
How to Prepare for a Workplace Investigation Interview
Practical guidance for anyone asked to attend a workplace investigation interview, whether as the complainant, the respondent, or a witness, so you can take part calmly and fairly.
The Positive Duty to Prevent Sexual Harassment: What It Means for Employers
Australian employers now have a positive duty to prevent workplace sexual harassment, not just respond to it. Here is what the duty requires and how to meet it.