Common Mistakes Employers Make in Workplace Investigations
A poorly run workplace investigation can be worse than no investigation at all. It can compound the original harm, destroy trust, and leave your organisation exposed if a finding is later challenged at the Fair Work Commission or in court.
The good news: most failures come down to a handful of avoidable mistakes. Here are the ones we see most often, and how to steer clear of them.
1. Vague or shifting allegations
If the allegations are not defined clearly at the start, the whole process wobbles. The respondent cannot fairly answer "you've been difficult to work with," and the investigator cannot test it.
Avoid it: draft specific, written allegations (particulars) before any interview, each a single, testable statement of who did what, to whom, and when. This is the foundation of the investigation process.
2. Failing to give procedural fairness
By far the most consequential mistake. Making a finding against someone who was never told the specific allegations, or never given a real chance to respond, undermines everything that follows.
Avoid it: put the particulars to the respondent, share the substance of the evidence, allow reasonable time and a support person, and genuinely consider their response. Our guide to procedural fairness covers this in depth.
3. Using an investigator who isn't impartial
Asking the complainant's manager, or anyone with a stake in the outcome, to investigate invites a claim of bias. Remember, perceived bias is enough to taint a finding.
Avoid it: choose someone genuinely neutral, and for serious or sensitive matters, consider an independent investigator.
4. Letting the process drag on
Delay prolongs distress, lets memories fade, and can itself be criticised as unreasonable. It is one of the most common complaints about internal investigations.
Avoid it: set a realistic timeframe up front, schedule interviews early, and give the matter dedicated attention. See How Long Should a Workplace Investigation Take?.
5. Over-promising confidentiality
Telling a complainant the matter will be "completely confidential" is a promise you cannot keep: the respondent must know the substance of what they are accused of.
Avoid it: promise discretion and explain that information will be shared only as far as a fair process requires.
6. Applying the wrong standard of proof
Some investigators look for proof "beyond reasonable doubt." That is the criminal standard and it does not apply.
Avoid it: make findings on the balance of probabilities, more likely than not, bearing in mind that more serious allegations require correspondingly stronger evidence (the Briginshaw principle).
7. Investigating when you should be supporting
An investigation is not always the right tool. Forcing a formal process onto low-level interpersonal conflict can inflame it.
Avoid it: triage first. Some matters are better resolved through a facilitated conversation or conflict resolution than a formal investigation.
8. Poor record-keeping
If it isn't documented, it effectively didn't happen. Gaps in the record make findings hard to defend.
Avoid it: keep accurate, contemporaneous notes of interviews, evidence, and decisions, and have witnesses confirm their statements.
9. Pre-judging the outcome
Going in convinced of the result, in either direction, corrupts the process and shows in the questions asked and the evidence weighed.
Avoid it: keep an open mind until all the evidence is gathered and the respondent has responded.
10. A confusing, jargon-filled report
A finding nobody can understand cannot be acted on with confidence. Reports padded with legalese or buried conclusions fail the people who have to make decisions.
Avoid it: insist on a clear, structured report that states the allegations, the evidence, the analysis, and the findings in plain language.
The common thread
Almost every mistake on this list traces back to two things: fairness and rigour. Build both into the process from the first day and you avoid the great majority of investigation failures.
Adomas Solutions brings extensive law enforcement experience and a court-level evidentiary approach to every workplace investigation: fair, thorough, and clearly reported. If you would like to discuss a matter, contact us for a confidential conversation, or browse our FAQ.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. For advice about a specific matter, contact us or seek independent legal counsel.
Keep reading
How to Prepare for a Workplace Investigation Interview
Practical guidance for anyone asked to attend a workplace investigation interview, whether as the complainant, the respondent, or a witness, so you can take part calmly and fairly.
The Positive Duty to Prevent Sexual Harassment: What It Means for Employers
Australian employers now have a positive duty to prevent workplace sexual harassment, not just respond to it. Here is what the duty requires and how to meet it.