What to Do When an Employee Makes a Bullying Complaint
A bullying complaint is one of the most sensitive situations a manager or HR team will ever handle. How you respond in the first few days shapes everything that follows: the wellbeing of the people involved, the strength of any later decision, and your organisation's exposure to legal and reputational risk.
This guide walks through what to do when an employee tells you they are being bullied, and the common traps to avoid.
First, understand what workplace bullying actually is
Under Australian work health and safety law, workplace bullying is repeated, unreasonable behaviour directed at a worker or group of workers that creates a risk to health and safety. Three elements matter:
- Repeated: a pattern of behaviour, not usually a single incident.
- Unreasonable: behaviour a reasonable person would see as victimising, humiliating, intimidating, or threatening.
- Risk to health and safety: including psychological health.
Importantly, reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable way is not bullying. Performance management, allocating work, and giving constructive feedback are legitimate, even when an employee finds them unwelcome. Part of your job is to separate genuine bullying from a dispute about reasonable management.
Step 1: Take it seriously and acknowledge the complaint
Whatever your initial read on the situation, treat every complaint as genuine until you know otherwise. Thank the employee for raising it, reassure them it will be handled properly and confidentially, and explain what happens next. Never dismiss a concern on the spot or suggest the person is overreacting.
You also have a duty of care. Ask whether the employee feels safe at work and whether any immediate support, such as an Employee Assistance Program (EAP), would help.
Step 2: Document what you have been told
Make a clear, factual record of the complaint: who, what, when, where, and who else may have witnessed it. Stick to what was said rather than your interpretation. This record becomes the foundation of any later process, so accuracy matters.
Step 3: Consider immediate interim measures
You may need to put temporary arrangements in place while the matter is assessed, for example, adjusting reporting lines, changing rosters, or agreeing on limited contact between the parties. Interim measures should protect wellbeing without pre-judging the outcome or punishing anyone. Frame them as neutral and temporary.
Step 4: Decide how the complaint will be handled
Not every complaint needs a full formal investigation. Depending on the seriousness and the facts, your options include:
- An early resolution or facilitated conversation: suitable for lower-level interpersonal conflict where both parties are willing.
- A formal investigation: appropriate for serious allegations, or where the facts are contested and a finding is needed before you can act.
If you are unsure which path fits, our workplace investigations team can help you triage the matter. For a sense of when an external investigator is the right call, see When to Use an Independent Investigator vs Investigating Internally.
Step 5: If you investigate, do it fairly
A defensible investigation follows the principles of procedural fairness: the person accused is told the specific allegations against them, given a genuine opportunity to respond, and the decision-maker approaches the matter without bias. Getting this wrong is the single most common reason findings are later overturned. We cover it in detail in Procedural Fairness in Workplace Investigations.
A typical process gathers documents, interviews the complainant, the respondent, and any witnesses, assesses the evidence against the civil standard (the balance of probabilities), and produces a written report with findings. See The Workplace Investigation Process in Australia for a full walkthrough.
Step 6: Support everyone through the process
Bullying complaints take a toll on the complainant, the respondent, and witnesses alike. Keep people informed of timeframes, maintain confidentiality, and remind everyone that victimising someone for making or participating in a complaint is itself a serious breach. A trauma-informed approach, one that prioritises dignity and psychological safety, leads to better evidence and better outcomes.
Step 7: Act on the findings
When the investigation is complete, use the findings to decide on next steps: that might be disciplinary action, mediation, training, changes to team structure, or policy improvements. Close the loop with the parties (to the extent appropriate) so they know the matter has been resolved.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Promising absolute confidentiality. You can promise discretion, but a fair process means the respondent must know the substance of the allegations.
- Letting it drift. Delay increases risk and distress. Set realistic timeframes and stick to them.
- Using the complainant's manager as investigator where there is any perceived bias.
- Pre-judging the outcome before the evidence is in.
For more on these, read Common Mistakes Employers Make in Workplace Investigations.
When to bring in external help
If the allegations are serious, the parties are senior, there is a risk of perceived bias, or you simply lack the internal capacity to run a fair process quickly, an independent investigator protects both your people and your organisation.
Adomas Solutions conducts impartial, trauma-informed workplace investigations across Tasmania and remotely throughout Australia. If you are dealing with a bullying complaint and want to talk it through, contact us for a confidential discussion. You may also find answers in our FAQ.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. For advice about a specific matter, contact us or seek independent legal counsel.
Keep reading
How to Prepare for a Workplace Investigation Interview
Practical guidance for anyone asked to attend a workplace investigation interview, whether as the complainant, the respondent, or a witness, so you can take part calmly and fairly.
The Positive Duty to Prevent Sexual Harassment: What It Means for Employers
Australian employers now have a positive duty to prevent workplace sexual harassment, not just respond to it. Here is what the duty requires and how to meet it.